US senate committee hears critical information on progress of CCS

A sitting of the US House Energy and Commerce Committee’s Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigation was given a comprehensive report on the state of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology’s progress this week in Washington.

The status of the technology was delivered as part of a review of the US Department of Energy’s (DOE)’s clean coal programmes.

Dr. Julio Friedmann, deputy assistant secretary for clean coal with the Department of Energy (DOE) told those present that because of coal’s continued relevance to US energy, that the development of CCS is ‘critical.’

He told the committee that the first generation of CCS technologies could increase wholesale power prices by 70- 80 per cent, but second generation technologies could halve those costs.

“I continue to believe that coal is actually a required part of a vibrant American economy—part of the future. In this context, the work we’re doing on CCS is critical. It is a key pathway forward for a sustainable, low carbon, energy future, with an era of abundance of fossil energy that we live in today.”

A most anticipated question by congress pertained to the cost of implementing CCS.

Dr. Friedmann said: “The precise number will vary by plant, whether it’s subcritical or supercritical, by coal rank, and by the kind of technology used. Typically, we express these costs as a range, so for the first generation technology, we’re looking at something on the order of $70 to $90 a tonne. In that context, that looks something like a 70% or 80% increase on the wholesale price of electricity. For the second-generation technologies, which we are developing, it’s our strong expectation that that number will be roughly half. We’ll be looking at something like a $40 or $50 a ton cost.”

Dr. Fredmann said that one pilot scheme being used by NRG was delivering a satisfactory return on investment. He noted government assistance has helped spur the success, but the return on investment from enhanced oil recovery revenues has also been significant. NRG has suggested that with the knowledge gained from the first project, it believes it can do a second project and get sizeable returns on investment without government assistance.

He added that the DOE is pursuing three technical pathways for carbon capture: post-combustion, pre-combustion, and oxygen-fired combustion or oxy-combustion.

“In terms of major milestones, we are looking towards a second generation of demonstrations coming forward in the next few years. They would be completely deployed and the learnings provided back to the public about the middle of the next decade—2022 to 2025 timeframe. Those second generation demonstrations would have substantially reduced costs,” he said.

Transformational technologies—those expected to reduce the costs of CCS to their lowest practical level—are expected to be commercially deployed in the field by 2025.

“On a thermodynamic and an engineering basis, they can get maybe another $10, another $15 a ton cheaper, so something on the order of $30 a ton is probably about the limit of what you can reasonably expect,” Friedmann said referring to the added cost of utilizing CCS.

For more coal-fired power generation news

Follow Power Engineering International on Twitter

Related Articles

Two coal-fired power plants set for Fukushima

Five Japanese firms have joined forces to construct two coal-fired power plants in Fukushima.

Circulating fluidized bed scrubber vs spray dryer absorber

The converging US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) rules for reducing mercury, metals, acid gases, organic compounds, SO2, NOx and particulates have ratcheted up the pressure on coal-fired generators to quickly reduce...

Latest Articles

Editor's Picks

GE unveils transformational Digital Power Plant

GE yesterday unveiled a digital initiative that it claims will revolutionise the power industry and save plant operators b...
Anne Carpenter of IEA Clean Coal Centre

Report highlights need for enlightened approach to water and power generation

The International Energy Agency’s Clean Coal Centre has produced its latest insights into what is referred to as the ‘wate...

UK gives £2bn backing to Hinkley Point nuclear project

The UK government has reaffirmed its commitment to Hinkley Point C new nuclear power station by unveiling a £2bn ($3.1bn) ...

Policy tinkering sees financial lure of UK renewables sector plummet

The UK’s attractiveness for renewables investment has plummeted in the last few months thanks to “policy-making in a vacuu...

US leapfrogs China to top renewables investment table

The US has leapfrogged China to the top slot in a highly-regarded annual analysis of the best countries in the world for r...

Editorial Guides

Lubrication Challenges for the Biogas Industry in 2015

The biogas industry is growing in importance as the world continues to look for alternative, clean energy sources. However...

Maximising Power Plant Efficiency

The need for power plants to operate at maximum efficiency and flexibility while cutting emissions is greater than ever be...

How to cut your OPEX

How to cut your OPEX In a constantly evolving electricity market, factors such as over capacity and low coal costs can pu...

Buyers Guide Companies

Rolls Royce Energy Systems

We supply gas turbines, compressors and diesel power units to customers ...

Bran & Luebbe, An SPX Brand

Bran & Luebbe, an SPX brand, has been a worldwide leader in metering, an...

Lenox Instrument Co

Lenox Instrument Co is a manufacturer of highly reliable fixed and porta...

ATG Electronics

For more than a decade, ATG Electronics has established itself as a lead...

SWAN Analytical Instruments AG

Is one of the leading manufacturers of online analytical instruments.

Buyers Guide Products

Excitation System

Our excitation systems are recognized worl...


Compact voltage regulator, integrates all ...

MHT410 Moisture, Hydrogen and Temperature Transmitter

The Vaisala Moisture, Hydrogen and Tempera...

DMT340 Series Dewpoint and Temperature Transmitters for Very Dry Conditions

The Vaisala DRYCAP® Dewpoint and Temperatu...

Control Servo Motor SMR

A Voith control servo motor is a linear el...

Power Engineering International


The Effect of Moisture Sensor Location on Reliable Transformer Oil Monitoring

Power transformers are among the most valuable and important assets in electrical power networks and moisture is one of the key factors impacting the operational performance of transformer oil.&nbs...

Engineering & Design for Lean Construction

AVEVA introduces the benefits of Engineering and Design for Lean Construction by challenging the concept of ‘right first time design' and presenting a ‘Lean’ approach. A Lean approach to project ex...

Bridging the Power Gap in Africa: Testing options to manage constrained short to medium term system operations

Around the world, existing power systems face increasingly constrained operations in the short to medium term with available ageing generation capacity.  In this paper, PLEXOS® has been used t...

AVEVA’s Digital Asset Approach - Defining a new era of collaboration in capital projects and asset operations

There is constant, intensive change in the capital projects and asset life cycle management. New challenges and opportunities are continually appearing thanks to dramatic developments in technology...

Latest Digital Edition

Look Inside >
Current Issue

Article Archives for Power Engineering International Magazine