Utilities criticize UK power market reform proposals

The proposed introduction of capacity payments to encourage the construction of back-up power plants has raised concern among industry executives in the UK, reports the Financial Times.
 
Under this proposal, generators would be given money to maintain power stations that are not generating electricity to ensure back-up capacity to deal with surges in demand. Nick Winser, director of transmission at transmission system operator National Grid, said the case for capacity payments had yet to be made, because the proposal seemed to pre-judge how much balancing of the market between types of generation would be needed.
 
“Whilst payment of some sort of fossil [fuel] standby plant may well be useful, it may well be that they constitute very little of the balancing need in the future,” he said, noting that storage of electricity and greater interconnection with Europe held great potential.
 
Dorothy Thompson, CEO of Drax, which runs Britain’s largest coal fired power station (4 GW), said the preferred option of having a “targeted capacity market” whereby the government would target specific types of generation, “could cause more problems than it solves”. Any structure that was agreed needed to consider how such an approach would deal with intermittency of supply.
 
Paul Golby, CEO of E.ON UK, also warned that while under the capacity mechanism the country would be spending “extra money to have that capacity”, the government should not ignore those fossil fuel plants that were already up and running.
 
“We have got a substantial amount of insurance in our existing oil plan. It just seems that in trying to balance [the market] it would be absolutely crazy to prematurely close out those plants that give us that capability.”
 
The executives were divided about the merits of a second proposal, where the government would agree long-term contracts with low-carbon generators, under which they would be entitled to top-up payments if wholesale prices fell too low to make a profit. If wholesale prices rose above a certain level the companies would have to return money to consumers.
 
The government has said it would prefer this to premium feed-in tariffs, under which generators would receive a fixed payment on top of the variable wholesale price, so the companies would still be taking on the market price risk.
 
The executives agreed, however, that the proposals would inevitably lead to a less liberalized market. Mr Golby noted that they would mean “a far more managed market”. He added: “That has implications for competition, for our companies and for the government”.
 
Chris Huhne, secretary of state for energy, said the intention “has been to use market mechanisms to the maximum extent possible”. “This is another type of market taking on board other objectives, including low carbon energy security,” he said.

The consultation lasts until spring, when recommendations will be published in a white paper.

For more business news, click here

 

Follow Power Engineering International on Twitter




Related Articles

Wind power sector looks to Iran

The wind industry is reportedly eyeing power project development in Iran as the anticipated end of sanctions in early 2016 opens new potential opportunities.

German onshore wind growth slows

Germany has installed about one-third less onshore wind power capacity so far this year than during the same period in 2014, new analysis shows.

Latest Articles
7 MW floating offshore wind turbine, Fukushima, Japan

Japan installs world's largest floating offshore wind turbine

The world's largest floating wind turbine was installed this week off the Japanese coast.

Baijo gas-fired power plant, Mexico

Start of operation for 205 MW Mexican gas-fired plant

Power generation firm InterGen has announced the start of commercial operation at its San Luis de la Paz gas-fired power plant in Mexico's Guanajuato state.

BC Hydro & Power's Revelstoke Dam in Canada

Hydropower to provide half of Canada’s energy by 2025

Canada’s hydropower capacity is predicted to grow to almost 85 GW by 2025, according to new research.


Editor's Picks

EU flag

Luxembourg government working on Hinkley Point C legal objection

As promised earlier this year, the Luxembourg government intends to file a lawsuit against the European Commission decisio...
David Cameron and Werner Faymann

Nuclear chief says Austrian legal action ‘damaging to efforts to address climate change’

The Austrian government has finally filed its legal challenge against the deal that facilitates subsidies for a nuclear po...
 Schleswig-Holstein Climate Minister Robert Habeck

Federal states applying pressure on Merkel government over subsidies to nuclear

States with green party representation in Germany are calling on the German government to take action against the prospect...
Mike Baston of Euracoal

Future global power generation mix – the coal-fired power perspective

In our inaugural PEi Google Hangout, Mike Bostan, Policy Officer at Euracoal tells Power Engineering International's Diarm...
Faymann

Austrian PM confirms lawsuit against Hinkley decision ready in weeks

Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann has confirmed that his country will be registering its lawsuit against the European Com...

Editorial Guides

Lubrication Challenges for the Biogas Industry in 2015

The biogas industry is growing in importance as the world continues to look for alternative, clean energy sources. However...

Maximising Power Plant Efficiency

The need for power plants to operate at maximum efficiency and flexibility while cutting emissions is greater than ever be...

How to cut your OPEX

How to cut your OPEX In a constantly evolving electricity market, factors such as over capacity and low coal costs can pu...

Buyers Guide Companies

ComRent International LLC

Offers rentals, sales, and services of load banks for testing generators...

Advanced Energy

Advanced Energy is a global leader in innovative power and control techn...

Fluid Energy Controls Inc

ACOEM AB

ACOEM is a supplier of Fixturlaser's innovative and user-friendly equipm...

CCI Thermal Technologies Inc

A leader in the development and manufacturing of industrial heating and ...

Buyers Guide Products

Bore Measurement

Typical applications are full bore measure...

Fixturlaser NXA Pro

This laser alignment system features many ...

Air Filtration

Braden filtration offers a wide range of f...

Exhaust Systems

Leader in Exhaust Bypass, Simple Cycle, Ex...

RETROFIT

Braden's retrofit strengths are divided in...

Power Engineering International

Whitepapers

Bridging the Power Gap in Africa: Testing options to manage constrained short to medium term system operations

Around the world, existing power systems face increasingly constrained operations in the short to medium term with available ageing generation capacity.  In this paper, PLEXOS® has been used t...

AVEVA’s Digital Asset Approach - Defining a new era of collaboration in capital projects and asset operations

There is constant, intensive change in the capital projects and asset life cycle management. New challenges and opportunities are continually appearing thanks to dramatic developments in technology...

The bottom line: engine oil impact on engine reliability

A reliable and well-maintained gas-powered engine performs consistently and continuously, which can lead to a healthier bottom line for plant operators. There is a raised awareness around the need ...

Understanding Moisture Dynamics in Power Transformers

In this webinar recording "Moisture Dynamics in Power Transformers" (held originally in September 23, 2014) you will have a chance to learn about the phenomena and its importance to your ...

Latest Digital Edition

  Power
  Engineering
  International
Look Inside >
Cover
Current Issue

Article Archives for Power Engineering International Magazine