Utilities criticize UK power market reform proposals

The proposed introduction of capacity payments to encourage the construction of back-up power plants has raised concern among industry executives in the UK, reports the Financial Times.
 
Under this proposal, generators would be given money to maintain power stations that are not generating electricity to ensure back-up capacity to deal with surges in demand. Nick Winser, director of transmission at transmission system operator National Grid, said the case for capacity payments had yet to be made, because the proposal seemed to pre-judge how much balancing of the market between types of generation would be needed.
 
“Whilst payment of some sort of fossil [fuel] standby plant may well be useful, it may well be that they constitute very little of the balancing need in the future,” he said, noting that storage of electricity and greater interconnection with Europe held great potential.
 
Dorothy Thompson, CEO of Drax, which runs Britain’s largest coal fired power station (4 GW), said the preferred option of having a “targeted capacity market” whereby the government would target specific types of generation, “could cause more problems than it solves”. Any structure that was agreed needed to consider how such an approach would deal with intermittency of supply.
 
Paul Golby, CEO of E.ON UK, also warned that while under the capacity mechanism the country would be spending “extra money to have that capacity”, the government should not ignore those fossil fuel plants that were already up and running.
 
“We have got a substantial amount of insurance in our existing oil plan. It just seems that in trying to balance [the market] it would be absolutely crazy to prematurely close out those plants that give us that capability.”
 
The executives were divided about the merits of a second proposal, where the government would agree long-term contracts with low-carbon generators, under which they would be entitled to top-up payments if wholesale prices fell too low to make a profit. If wholesale prices rose above a certain level the companies would have to return money to consumers.
 
The government has said it would prefer this to premium feed-in tariffs, under which generators would receive a fixed payment on top of the variable wholesale price, so the companies would still be taking on the market price risk.
 
The executives agreed, however, that the proposals would inevitably lead to a less liberalized market. Mr Golby noted that they would mean “a far more managed market”. He added: “That has implications for competition, for our companies and for the government”.
 
Chris Huhne, secretary of state for energy, said the intention “has been to use market mechanisms to the maximum extent possible”. “This is another type of market taking on board other objectives, including low carbon energy security,” he said.

The consultation lasts until spring, when recommendations will be published in a white paper.

For more business news, click here

 

Follow Power Engineering International on Twitter

Editor's Picks

Mike Winkel of E.ON

E.ON calls for assistance in renewables investment drive

Germany’s largest utility says it can no longer afford to push large renewable projects on its own and is looking for part...
Polish flag

Poland's 2050 policy outlines move away from coal

The Polish government has published a draft energy policy, which looks to reduce dependency on coal in favour of a low-car...
Doel

Belgium braces for power cuts

The Belgian government is making contingency plans as the impact of the closure of half its nuclear capacity looks set to ...
Dr Stephen Mills

Turkey’s coal resource a potential economic boon – IEA CCC report

A report on the Turkish power sector has found that Turkey can significantly reduce its energy import bill by focusing its...
Meike van Ginneken, the World Bank Group's Energy Practice Manager for Central & West Africa

Giant hydroelectric project tallies with World Bank’s mission

Meike van Ginneken, the World Bank Group's Energy Practice Manager for Central & West Africa, explains why the bank is...

PEI Magazine Issues



>> Current Issue           >> Past Issues

Latest Wire News

Pulstar Launches New Website

Pulstar Launches New Website

XZERES to Present at the 2014 Gateway Conference on September 4

XZERES to Present at the 2014 Gateway Conference on September 4

Algeco Scotsman Appoints Rick Bennett as Vice President and General Manager of Remote Accommodations Division in Canada and Alaska

Algeco Scotsman Appoints Rick Bennett as Vice President and General Manager of Remote Accomm...

Quantum Energy Secures 2nd Bakken Refinery Site

Quantum Energy Secures 2nd Bakken Refinery Site

Consumer Packaged Goods Companies Must Plan for a Digital Future

Consumer Packaged Goods Companies Must Plan for a Digital Future

Editorial Guides

How to cut your OPEX

How to cut your OPEX In a constantly evolving electricity market, factors such as over capacity and low coal costs can pu...

Alstom Editorial Guide: Thailand to showcase latest upgrade of Alstom's GT26 in combined-cycle

Read all about Alstom's new advanced GT26 gas turbine in the North Bangkok CCPP expansion project online with the Power En...

PLEXOS® Integrated Energy Model – Leading the Field in Energy Market Modelling

PLEXOS® Integrated Energy Modelling is an advanced software tool that employs the latest mathematical programming methods ...

Power Engineering International

Whitepapers

Portfolio Optimization by PLEXOS

PLEXOS performs the Security Constrained Unit Commitment and Economic Dispatch using Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) to minimize a cost function subject to all operational constraints. The PLEXOS M...

Evaluating cogeneration for your facility: A look at the potential energy-efficiency, economic and environmental benefits

The energy-efficiency, economic and environmental benefits of cogeneration are the subject of this in-depth white paper. The paper argues that producing electricity and heat/cooling from the same f...

The Effect of Moisture on the Breakdown Voltage of Transformer Oil

Power transformers utilize oil as a heat transfer medium and a dielectric material, together with cellulose. Breakdown voltage (dielectric strength) is one of the most important parameters of trans...

Improving Mission Critical Cooling Systems With More Reliable Level Sensing

The choice of coolant level sensor may seem like an insignificant detail when designing complex machinery such as emergency generators and cranes, but if this sensor fails, the operator has no warn...

Steps Towards a Low Carbon Future: Solutions and Technologies That Will Support the Global Revolution Required

A smart grid is becoming more and more essential as clean energy becomes more dominant. In addition, the demand for electricity is expected to treble the ability to supply it over the next decade. ...

Latest Digital Edition

  Power
  Engineering
  International
Look Inside >
Cover
Current Issue

Article Archives for Power Engineering International Magazine

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>